VariantWise Observatory · finding 2
What an automatic actually costs
Two pedals or three is the question almost every ladder asks somewhere near the middle, and the brochure never answers it in one number. Across the 277 trim-and-engine combinations sold both ways, the automatic costs a median of ₹1.10L more than the identical manual, 8% of the car, for the same trim, the same engine and the same kit. The smallest step anyone asks is ₹37,000 and the largest is ₹4.20L, a spread of 11 to one on what is mechanically the same decision.
And the choice is rarer than a showroom makes it feel. Of the 817 trim-and-engine combinations on sale, only 277 offer you both, and only 72 of the 126 models on sale let you choose anywhere in their range. The other 540 combinations come one way only, counted and explained in the method below.
The automatic premium by brand. The bar is the full range from that brand’s cheapest step to its dearest, the orange mark is the median, and the figure beside it is that median. Free to republish with credit to VariantWise.
Some badges charge several times what others do
The median step runs from ₹50,000 at one end of the market to ₹3.09L at the other. Part of that is the cars: a maker whose range is mostly large SUVs is pricing a bigger gearbox on a dearer car. Part of it is policy, and the ranges show it, because a brand that prices the choice consistently has a short bar however high its median sits.
| Brand | Median step | Share of the car | Cheapest to dearest | Pairs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jeep | ₹3.09L | 12% | ₹2.06L to ₹4.20L | 5 |
| Mahindra | ₹1.50L | 8% | ₹76,000 to ₹1.72L | 35 |
| Toyota | ₹1.33L | 9% | ₹51,000 to ₹2.21L | 14 |
| Kia | ₹1.28L | 9% | ₹75,000 to ₹1.45L | 25 |
| Citroen | ₹1.17L | 9% | ₹71,000 to ₹1.27L | 5 |
| Volkswagen | ₹1.15L | 8% | ₹1.09L to ₹1.20L | 7 |
| MG | ₹1.15L | 8% | ₹1.10L to ₹1.20L | 5 |
| Hyundai | ₹1.02L | 9% | ₹48,000 to ₹1.45L | 33 |
| Honda | ₹1.00L | 8% | ₹61,000 to ₹1.17L | 10 |
| Skoda | ₹1.00L | 8% | ₹80,000 to ₹2.20L | 11 |
| Renault | ₹70,000 | 9% | ₹37,000 to ₹1.50L | 12 |
| Nissan | ₹58,000 | 8% | ₹55,000 to ₹1.50L | 12 |
| Tata | ₹56,000 | 8% | ₹44,000 to ₹1.91L | 60 |
| Maruti Suzuki | ₹50,000 | 9% | ₹40,000 to ₹1.95L | 43 |
The bigger the car, the dearer the choice
Every step up in body style makes the same decision cost more. The median automatic asks ₹54,500 in the Hatchback class and ₹1.35L in the MPV class, about 2.5 times as much for a decision that has not changed. Worth knowing before you assume the automatic is a rounding error on a big car: as a share of the price it is 11% there against 8% at the small end, so it gets steeper in both senses.
| Body style | Median step | Share of the car | Cheapest to dearest | Pairs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MPV | ₹1.35L | 11% | ₹48,000 to ₹1.58L | 15 |
| SUV | ₹1.27L | 9% | ₹44,000 to ₹4.20L | 185 |
| Sedan | ₹1.00L | 7% | ₹40,000 to ₹1.34L | 25 |
| Hatchback | ₹54,500 | 8% | ₹37,000 to ₹1.19L | 52 |
The two ends, and why they are different cars
The cheapest automatic decision in the catalogue is the Renault Kwid Evolution Petrol, where the self-shifting version asks ₹37,000 more than the manual (₹4.53L against ₹4.90L). The dearest is the Jeep Meridian Longitude Diesel, at ₹4.20L. Neither is the steepest as a share of the car: that is the Skoda Kushaq Classic+ Turbo Petrol, where the gearbox adds 21% to the bill. A buyer weighing that one is being asked for a fifth of the car’s price to stop changing gears, which is worth saying out loud before a salesperson calls it a small upgrade.
Method, in full
A pair is two variants of the same model in the SAME trim with the SAME engine, one manual and one automatic. That is what makes the difference a gearbox price rather than a trim step: in this catalogue the equipment list belongs to the trim and the driven wheels belong to the engine, so both halves of every pair carry identical kit and identical drive by construction. Clutchless manuals count as manuals, because the driver still changes every gear. Where a combination offers two automatics, the cheaper one is used, since the honest answer to what it costs to stop shifting is the smallest step that buys it. Prices are ex-showroom, from the same catalogue that prices this site’s own pages.
Nothing is dropped quietly. Of 817 combinations, 257 are sold as a manual only, 143 are sold as an automatic only and 140 are electric, so there is only ever one gearbox; the remaining 277 are the pairs above, and those counts add back to the whole. Medians rather than averages, because a handful of large diesel SUVs would drag a mean away from what most buyers are actually quoted. A brand or body style needs 5 pairs before its median is published, and today none fall short; every row carries its count so you can see how thin the thin ones are. This page recomputed 2026-09-06, and it recomputes with every data update, so it does not rot the way a published table does.
The variant-by-variant prices behind it are free to download and reuse with attribution on the open data page, the first finding in this series prices the same car across every state, and the scoring behind the site is on how we rank.