What owners actually say
Crash tests, long-term reviews and owner reports, distilled per car. Never the maker's marketing, and never only the good news. 29 of 97 cars have scored, evidence-backed verdicts so far; the research runs daily and the rest join as the evidence lands.
Hatchbacks
7 of 14 researched
Tata Altroz
Excellent safetyFive Bharat NCAP stars across petrol, diesel and CNG, not just one variant
Diesel DPF trouble at roughly 8,000 km intervals in mostly short city driving, progressing to oil dilution

Maruti Suzuki Baleno
Excellent resale valueThe best interior quality Maruti has managed, with soft-touch surfaces and rich plastic textures
Three stars for child occupant protection at Bharat NCAP

Maruti Suzuki Wagon R
Excellent resale valueA genuinely roomy cabin for the money, with the tall-boy shape making it easy to get in and out of
One star for adults and zero for children at Global NCAP in 2023, the weakest crash result in this catalogue

Maruti Suzuki Swift
Excellent resale valueSix airbags, ESP, hill-hold, ABS with EBD and ISOFIX as standard equipment
No Bharat NCAP result has been published for the India-built car, and the Euro NCAP three stars are for the Japan-built model

Hyundai i20
Good running costsOwners reaching six years and 43,000 km with nothing failing
Global NCAP called the bodyshell unstable and flagged weak chest protection for the driver

Tata Tiago
Average reliabilityFeels sturdier and better built than the price suggests, a reputation it has held since launch
The air conditioning takes its time and loses ground in stop-start traffic, which owners name as the main irritation

Tata Tiago EV
Average reliabilityHigh mileage owners report the motor and battery giving no trouble, one at 47,000km over three years and another at 38,000km
No crash test result exists for the Tiago EV, from any programme, and the petrol car's four star rating does not transfer to it
Not enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
Sedans
3 of 10 researched
Hyundai Verna
Excellent safetyFive stars from Global NCAP for adults and children, under the stricter 2022 rules, on the base car
Global NCAP judged the bodyshell unstable, and noted a child seat failure after the side impact

Maruti Suzuki Dzire
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP protection for adults and children, on the base variant upwards
The 81 hp, 112 Nm three-cylinder is down on the outgoing four-cylinder and feels it

Tata Tigor
Good resale valueSecond only to the Dzire for holding its value among compact sedans
Fit and finish lets it down, with rattles from the B and C pillars over poor surfaces reported repeatedly
Not enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
SUVs
18 of 58 researched
Tata Nexon EV
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP result, 29.86 of 32 for adults and 44.95 of 49 for children
Charger red-light fault that owners report returning even after the charger is replaced

Tata Punch
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP protection on the 2026 facelift, 30.58 of 32 for adults
Fit and finish: panel gaps and rattles reported as a daily annoyance

Tata Nexon
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP crash protection for adults and children alike
Recurring electrical faults, including a recalled PEPS ESCL part on May 2023 cars

Tata Harrier
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP result, 30.08 of 32 for adults, among the first cars India tested
Rattles from door pads and the B-pillar reported across multiple long-term owners

Tata Safari
Excellent safetyFive Bharat NCAP stars and a Global NCAP Safer Choice Award
Infotainment and cluster glitches, including screens blanking while driving

Tata Punch EV
Excellent safetyBharat NCAP adult score of 31.09 of 32 on the facelift, standard across variants
Wide and uneven panel gaps, worn door beading and a noisy radiator fan

Maruti Suzuki Brezza
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP protection for adults and children
Feels top-heavy through corners, with steering Autocar India describes as disconnected

Hyundai Creta
Good running costsEngines and gearboxes that long-term testers and owners alike report needing nothing but scheduled servicing
No crash rating exists for the India-spec car on sale today

Tata Harrier EV
Excellent safetyMaximum 32 of 32 Bharat NCAP adult protection score
Real-world range of 401km against a 622km claim on Autocar India's test

Hyundai Venue
Excellent safetyFive-star Bharat NCAP result, 31.15 of 32 for adults, and it applies to every variant including the N Line
Petrol versions lose value much faster than the diesel manual in years four and five

Tata Curvv EV
Excellent safetyRefinement is the thing owners and testers keep coming back to: no vibration, no idle thrum, just a smooth surge
Real range lands roughly 25 percent short of the 502km claim in every published full-charge test

Kia Seltos
Excellent safetyRide comfort, the old car's weak point, retuned so it no longer crashes over broken roads
Styling that reviewers call divisive, much more aggressive than the car it replaces

Mahindra Scorpio-N
Good safetyThe 2.2 mHawk diesel and its gearbox, still smooth and strong at 50,000 to 65,000 km
Software and electronics niggles: instrument clusters going blank, Android Auto and CarPlay dropping out, hill hold assist that does not always engage

Maruti Suzuki Fronx
Good resale valueFuel economy is the headline: Autocar India's long-termer sat around 18kpl and owners report 15kpl in mixed traffic and 22kpl on a long run
No Bharat NCAP rating, and the two overseas tests of the India-built car disagree by three stars

Mahindra Thar Roxx
Excellent safetyThe safest score any petrol or diesel car has managed at Bharat NCAP, and the first ladder-frame SUV to take five stars
Electrical niggles reported by a magazine long-termer and owners alike, including the instrument cluster going blank while driving

Tata Curvv
Excellent safetyA five star Bharat NCAP result that applies across the range, not just to the loaded variant
Rear seat space and comfort are not the best in class, and the coupe roofline costs headroom if you are over six feet

Maruti Suzuki e Vitara
Excellent safetyFive stars at Bharat NCAP for adults and children, 31.49 of 32 and 43 of 49
Too new to have an ownership record: no owner mileage reports, service invoices or used values exist for it yet

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara
Average reliabilityThe strong hybrid's economy is the reason to buy it: Autocar India measured 22.08kpl overall, 23.77 in the city, and saw 21 to 22kpl across 7,000 km of long-term running
No Bharat NCAP or Global NCAP rating has ever been published for it, despite Autocar India reporting it was among the first Marutis lined up for testing
Not enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
MPVs
1 of 12 researchedNot enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
Vans
0 of 1 researchedNot enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
Pickups
0 of 1 researchedNot enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
Convertibles
0 of 1 researchedNot enough independent evidence yet
The research runs daily; these join with scores the day enough sources agree.
Every score links to its sources on the car's own page. Scores come only from independent press, testing bodies and owner evidence, never from the maker, and a car with too little independent evidence shows no score rather than a guessed one.

