VariantWise

Mercedes-Benz S-Class vs Porsche Taycan: which should you buy?

The full picture

The Porsche Taycan starts at ₹2.01Cr against the Mercedes-Benz S-Class's ₹2.20Cr ex-showroom, so it is ₹19.30L cheaper to get into.

They run together up to ₹2.38Cr, where the S-Class tops out. Past that only the Taycan has anything left to sell you, up to ₹2.74Cr.

Only one of them takes the whole party: the S-Class seats 5, the Taycan 4.

Fuel is a real difference here: the S-Class comes in plug-in hybrid, the Taycan in electric.

Same money, which car?

Take ₹2.38Cr to both showrooms and you come out with the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition at ₹2.38Cr or the Taycan 4S Black Edition at ₹2.09Cr, the Taycan leaving ₹28.55L of that in your pocket.

Mercedes-Benz S-Class

Mercedes-Benz S-Class

S450e Manufaktur Edition Plug-in Hybrid AT
₹2.38Cr
ex-showroom Delhi
Porsche Taycan

Porsche Taycan

4S Black Edition Electric AT
₹2.09Cr
ex-showroom Delhi
₹28.55L of the budget left over

Our take

We'd go for the Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition

The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition is not worth the extra ₹28.55L.

For ₹28.55L more, the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition would get you

  • 15 airbags, up from 8
  • Level 2 (full suite) ADAS, up from level 1
  • Tri-screen cabin layout
  • Ventilated front seats
  • Head-up display
  • 14.4" touchscreen, up from 10.9"
  • Wireless CarPlay / Android Auto
  • More in the table below

Also worth knowing

  • Only the Mercedes-Benz S-Class seats 5, worth knowing if you need the space
  • The Taycan is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
  • The Taycan 4S Black Edition is the stronger of the two at 598 PS
Choose the Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition if
You want the better value for money, and to save the ₹28.55LOnly this one has second-row captain seats, 14-way powered driver seat, electronic parking brake + auto hold
Choose the Mercedes-Benz S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition if
You need the 5 seatsOnly this one has 15 airbags, level 2 (full suite) ADAS, tri-screen cabin layout
Read the full reasoning

The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition's case is 15 airbags against 8, level 2 (full suite) ADAS against level 1 and tri-screen cabin layout, but ₹28.55L is steep for it. The Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition keeps the essentials and the difference in your pocket.

  • Only the Mercedes-Benz S-Class seats 5, worth knowing if you need the space
  • The Taycan is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
  • The Taycan 4S Black Edition is the stronger of the two at 598 PS
  • Also on the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition: ventilated front seats, head-up display, 14.4" touchscreen against 10.9" and wireless CarPlay / Android Auto, with more worth seeing in the table below

Put these two side by side, spec for spec →

S-Class vs Taycan, on paper

SpecMercedes-Benz S-ClassPorsche Taycan
Price (ex-showroom)₹2.20Cr to ₹2.38Cr₹2.01Cr to ₹2.74Cr
Variants23
Body typeLuxury SedanLuxury Performance Electric Sedan
Seats54
FuelsPlug-in hybridElectric
Boot345 litres407 litres
Length5,304 mm4,963 mm
Width1,921 mm1,966 mm
Wheelbase3,216 mm2,900 mm
Fuel tank67 litres-
Turning radius5.85 m5.85 m

Whichever you pick, the variant is where the money goes

S-Class vs Taycan: the questions people ask

Is the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or the Porsche Taycan cheaper?
The Porsche Taycan, by ₹19.30L: it starts at ₹2.01Cr against ₹2.20Cr ex-showroom for the S-Class. Both run well past that, so what you actually pay depends on the variant.
Mercedes-Benz S-Class vs Porsche Taycan: which gives you more for the same money?
At ₹2.38Cr it is the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition against the Taycan 4S Black Edition. The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition's case is 15 airbags against 8, level 2 (full suite) ADAS against level 1 and tri-screen cabin layout, but ₹28.55L is steep for it. The Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition keeps the essentials and the difference in your pocket.
Which is more practical, the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or the Porsche Taycan?
On the figures the makers publish, the S-Class seats 5 against the Taycan's 4 and the Taycan swallows 407 litres of luggage against 345. Everything else about living with them, from boot shape to how the back seat actually feels, is a test drive question rather than a spec sheet one.

Prices are ex-showroom and change without notice. Specifications are compiled from public sources; always confirm with a dealer before buying.