Mercedes-Benz S-Class vs Porsche Taycan: which should you buy?
The full picture
The Porsche Taycan starts at ₹2.01Cr against the Mercedes-Benz S-Class's ₹2.20Cr ex-showroom, so it is ₹19.30L cheaper to get into.
They run together up to ₹2.38Cr, where the S-Class tops out. Past that only the Taycan has anything left to sell you, up to ₹2.74Cr.
Only one of them takes the whole party: the S-Class seats 5, the Taycan 4.
Fuel is a real difference here: the S-Class comes in plug-in hybrid, the Taycan in electric.
Same money, which car?
Take ₹2.38Cr to both showrooms and you come out with the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition at ₹2.38Cr or the Taycan 4S Black Edition at ₹2.09Cr, the Taycan leaving ₹28.55L of that in your pocket.
Our take
We'd go for the Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition
The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition is not worth the extra ₹28.55L.
For ₹28.55L more, the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition would get you
- 15 airbags, up from 8
- Level 2 (full suite) ADAS, up from level 1
- Tri-screen cabin layout
- Ventilated front seats
- Head-up display
- 14.4" touchscreen, up from 10.9"
- Wireless CarPlay / Android Auto
- More in the table below
Also worth knowing
- Only the Mercedes-Benz S-Class seats 5, worth knowing if you need the space
- The Taycan is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
- The Taycan 4S Black Edition is the stronger of the two at 598 PS
- Choose the Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition if
- You want the better value for money, and to save the ₹28.55LOnly this one has second-row captain seats, 14-way powered driver seat, electronic parking brake + auto hold
- Choose the Mercedes-Benz S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition if
- You need the 5 seatsOnly this one has 15 airbags, level 2 (full suite) ADAS, tri-screen cabin layout
Read the full reasoning
The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition's case is 15 airbags against 8, level 2 (full suite) ADAS against level 1 and tri-screen cabin layout, but ₹28.55L is steep for it. The Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition keeps the essentials and the difference in your pocket.
- Only the Mercedes-Benz S-Class seats 5, worth knowing if you need the space
- The Taycan is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
- The Taycan 4S Black Edition is the stronger of the two at 598 PS
- Also on the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition: ventilated front seats, head-up display, 14.4" touchscreen against 10.9" and wireless CarPlay / Android Auto, with more worth seeing in the table below
S-Class vs Taycan, on paper
| Spec | Mercedes-Benz S-Class | Porsche Taycan |
|---|---|---|
| Price (ex-showroom) | ₹2.20Cr to ₹2.38Cr | ₹2.01Cr to ₹2.74Cr |
| Variants | 2 | 3 |
| Body type | Luxury Sedan | Luxury Performance Electric Sedan |
| Seats | 5 | 4 |
| Fuels | Plug-in hybrid | Electric |
| Boot | 345 litres | 407 litres |
| Length | 5,304 mm | 4,963 mm |
| Width | 1,921 mm | 1,966 mm |
| Wheelbase | 3,216 mm | 2,900 mm |
| Fuel tank | 67 litres | - |
| Turning radius | 5.85 m | 5.85 m |
Whichever you pick, the variant is where the money goes
S-Class vs Taycan: the questions people ask
- Is the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or the Porsche Taycan cheaper?
- The Porsche Taycan, by ₹19.30L: it starts at ₹2.01Cr against ₹2.20Cr ex-showroom for the S-Class. Both run well past that, so what you actually pay depends on the variant.
- Mercedes-Benz S-Class vs Porsche Taycan: which gives you more for the same money?
- At ₹2.38Cr it is the S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition against the Taycan 4S Black Edition. The S-Class S450e Manufaktur Edition's case is 15 airbags against 8, level 2 (full suite) ADAS against level 1 and tri-screen cabin layout, but ₹28.55L is steep for it. The Porsche Taycan 4S Black Edition keeps the essentials and the difference in your pocket.
- Which is more practical, the Mercedes-Benz S-Class or the Porsche Taycan?
- On the figures the makers publish, the S-Class seats 5 against the Taycan's 4 and the Taycan swallows 407 litres of luggage against 345. Everything else about living with them, from boot shape to how the back seat actually feels, is a test drive question rather than a spec sheet one.
Prices are ex-showroom and change without notice. Specifications are compiled from public sources; always confirm with a dealer before buying.


