VariantWise

Land Rover Discovery vs Porsche Macan Electric: which should you buy?

The full picture

The Porsche Macan Electric starts at ₹1.22Cr against the Land Rover Discovery's ₹1.26Cr ex-showroom, so it is ₹4.38L cheaper to get into.

They run together up to ₹1.39Cr, where the Discovery tops out. Past that only the Macan Electric has anything left to sell you, up to ₹1.78Cr.

Only one of them takes the whole party: the Discovery seats 7, the Macan Electric 5.

Fuel is a real difference here: the Discovery comes in diesel, the Macan Electric in electric.

Same money, which car?

Take ₹1.39Cr to both showrooms and you come out with the Discovery Tempest at ₹1.39Cr or the Macan Electric Electric at ₹1.22Cr, the Macan Electric leaving ₹17.44L of that in your pocket.

Land Rover Discovery

Land Rover Discovery

Tempest Diesel Mild Hybrid AT
₹1.39Cr
ex-showroom Delhi
Porsche Macan Electric

Porsche Macan Electric

Electric Electric AT
₹1.22Cr
ex-showroom Delhi
₹17.44L of the budget left over

Our take

It's your call

There's no clear winner: it comes down to whether you would pay ₹17.44L for 360° camera, bi-LED + booster lamp headlamps against bi-LED projector and ventilated front seats.

For ₹17.44L more, the Discovery Tempest gets you

  • 360° camera
  • Bi-LED + booster lamp headlamps, up from bi-LED projector
  • Ventilated front seats
  • Hill descent control
  • 11.4" touchscreen, up from 10.9"
  • Head-up display
  • Connected car tech
  • Rear ventilated seats
  • 20-way powered driver seat, up from 8-way
  • More in the table below

Also worth knowing

  • Only the Land Rover Discovery seats 7, worth knowing if you need the space
  • The Macan Electric swallows more luggage at 540 litres
  • The Macan Electric is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
Choose the Porsche Macan Electric Electric if
You would rather save the ₹17.44L, and as the electric it is the cheaper of the two to runOnly this one has drive modes, regenerative braking
Choose the Land Rover Discovery Tempest if
You need the 7 seatsOnly this one has 360° camera, bi-LED + booster lamp headlamps, ventilated front seats
Read the full reasoning

₹17.44L more gets you 360° camera, bi-LED + booster lamp headlamps against bi-LED projector and ventilated front seats on the Discovery Tempest. The useful extras on top: hill descent control and 11.4" touchscreen against 10.9". Fair if those top your list, easy to skip if not.

  • Only the Land Rover Discovery seats 7, worth knowing if you need the space
  • The Macan Electric swallows more luggage at 540 litres
  • The Macan Electric is electric, so it will be the cheaper of the two to run
  • Also on the Discovery Tempest: head-up display, connected car tech, rear ventilated seats and 20-way powered driver seat against 8-way, with more worth seeing in the table below

Put these two side by side, spec for spec →

Discovery vs Macan Electric, on paper

SpecLand Rover DiscoveryPorsche Macan Electric
Price (ex-showroom)₹1.26Cr to ₹1.39Cr₹1.22Cr to ₹1.78Cr
Variants33
Body typeMidsize Luxury SUVLuxury Electric SUV
Seats75
FuelsDieselElectric
Boot172 litres540 litres
Length4,956 mm4,784 mm
Width2,073 mm1,938 mm
Wheelbase2,923 mm2,893 mm
Ground clearance207 mm-
Fuel tank85 litres-
Turning radius6.21 m6.05 m

Whichever you pick, the variant is where the money goes

Discovery vs Macan Electric: the questions people ask

Is the Land Rover Discovery or the Porsche Macan Electric cheaper?
The Porsche Macan Electric, by ₹4.38L: it starts at ₹1.22Cr against ₹1.26Cr ex-showroom for the Discovery. Both run well past that, so what you actually pay depends on the variant.
Land Rover Discovery vs Porsche Macan Electric: which gives you more for the same money?
At ₹1.39Cr it is the Discovery Tempest against the Macan Electric Electric. ₹17.44L more gets you 360° camera, bi-LED + booster lamp headlamps against bi-LED projector and ventilated front seats on the Discovery Tempest. The useful extras on top: hill descent control and 11.4" touchscreen against 10.9". Fair if those top your list, easy to skip if not.
Which is more practical, the Land Rover Discovery or the Porsche Macan Electric?
On the figures the makers publish, the Discovery seats 7 against the Macan Electric's 5 and the Macan Electric swallows 540 litres of luggage against 172. Everything else about living with them, from boot shape to how the back seat actually feels, is a test drive question rather than a spec sheet one.

Prices are ex-showroom and change without notice. Specifications are compiled from public sources; always confirm with a dealer before buying.